Book Apointment

Different Types of Tree Spades: Hydraulic vs. Mechanical

Tree spades are essential tools for transplanting trees efficiently and safely by digging out the root ball intact. Among the various types available, hydraulic tree spades and mechanical tree spades are the two main categories, each with distinct designs, advantages, and limitations. Understanding their differences can help landscapers, arborists, and nurseries choose the best tool for their specific needs.

What is a Tree Spade?

A tree spade attachment is a specialized machine with multiple large, curved blades that dig around a tree’s root system to remove it along with a substantial root ball and surrounding soil. This minimizes root damage and transplant shock, improving the survival rate of the tree after relocation.

Hydraulic Tree Spades

Hydraulic tree spades use a system of hydraulic cylinders and pumps powered by the host machine’s hydraulic system—typically tractors, skid steers, or truck-mounted platforms. The operator controls the blades’ movement using hydraulic pressure, allowing precise and powerful digging and lifting.

Features and Operation

  • Hydraulic Blades: Blades move simultaneously via hydraulic cylinders, driving into the soil smoothly and evenly.
  • Precision Control: The operator controls the blade depth and angle with hydraulic joysticks, allowing adjustment to different soil types and tree sizes.
  • Powerful Digging Force: Hydraulic pressure enables the blades to cut through tough soils, roots, and compacted ground effectively.
  • Versatility: Can be mounted on various machinery with hydraulic systems, including skid steers, tractors, and trucks.
  • Blade Configurations: Usually equipped with 3 or 4 blades forming a conical root ball cut.

Advantages of Hydraulic Tree Spades

  • Smooth and Consistent Operation: Hydraulic systems provide steady, controllable blade movement, reducing the risk of root ball breakage.
  • Higher Efficiency: Faster digging and lifting cycles increase productivity.
  • Better for Larger Trees and Tough Soils: The power of hydraulics makes it possible to transplant larger trees and handle rocky or heavy clay soils.
  • Operator Ease: Controls are intuitive, requiring less manual effort compared to mechanical systems.

Limitations

  • Higher Initial Cost: Hydraulic tree spades tend to be more expensive due to complex hydraulic components.
  • Maintenance: Hydraulic systems require regular maintenance to prevent leaks, ensure fluid quality, and maintain cylinder integrity.
  • Dependency on Machinery Hydraulic System: The host machine must have a compatible hydraulic system with sufficient flow and pressure.

Mechanical Tree Spades

Mechanical tree spades operate through manual or mechanical means such as levers, gears, or chains without reliance on hydraulic power. These are typically older designs or simpler attachments used on smaller machines or in specialized situations.

Features and Operation

  • Manual or Mechanical Actuation: Blades move using manual force (lever systems) or mechanical linkages powered by the machine’s PTO (power take-off) or engine.
  • Simpler Construction: Fewer moving parts and no hydraulic hoses or cylinders.
  • Basic Blade Movement: Blade insertion and lifting may be controlled through crank handles, ratchets, or mechanical linkages.
  • Limited Blade Configurations: Usually fewer blades or less adjustable angles compared to hydraulic spades.

Advantages of Mechanical Tree Spades

  • Lower Cost: Simpler design and fewer components reduce purchase price and maintenance costs.
  • Easier Repairs: Mechanical parts are often easier to repair in the field without specialized tools.
  • Independence from Hydraulic Systems: Can be used with machines lacking hydraulic power or where hydraulic service is limited.

Limitations

  • Labor-Intensive Operation: Manual blade movement requires more operator strength and effort.
  • Less Precise Control: Blade insertion depth and angle are harder to adjust precisely, risking uneven root balls or root damage.
  • Slower Process: Mechanical systems typically work slower, reducing overall efficiency.
  • Limited Capacity: Mechanical spades generally can handle smaller trees and softer soils.

Choosing Between Hydraulic and Mechanical Tree Spades

Factors to consider when selecting a tree spade type include:

  • Tree Size and Type: For larger trees or species with extensive root systems, hydraulic spades provide the necessary power and precision.
  • Soil Conditions: Tough, rocky, or compacted soils favor hydraulic systems due to their digging force.
  • Machinery Compatibility: If the available machine has a hydraulic system with adequate flow, a hydraulic tree spade is preferable. For smaller machines or simple setups, mechanical spades might be more practical.
  • Budget and Maintenance: Mechanical tree spades have lower upfront and maintenance costs but may cost more in labor and slower operation.
  • Frequency of Use: For regular, commercial-scale transplanting, hydraulic spades improve productivity and reliability. For occasional or light use, mechanical spades might suffice.

Summary

Hydraulic tree spades are modern, efficient, and powerful, best suited for larger trees, tough soils, and frequent transplanting work. They offer precision, speed, and ease of operation but come with higher costs and maintenance demands.

Mechanical tree spades are simpler, more affordable options for smaller trees and softer soils, ideal when hydraulic systems aren’t available or budgets are tight. However, they require more manual effort and provide less precision.

Understanding these differences helps professionals choose the right tree spade to maximize tree survival, operational efficiency, and overall project success.